Postcard from Bayreuth


I was about 400 metres away when it dawned on me, what it reminded me of. I had taken a week by myself to visit the Wagner music festival in the small Bavarian town of Bayreuth. It was this Summer, the weather was glorious and I had tickets to the Ring Cycle, Wagner’s masterpiece of musical theatre, four long operas to be seen over six days, about fifteen hours of music in all. Wagner had built his own theatre on the outskirts of the town in the mid-19th century and it is still there, has been playing his – and only his – music for very nearly 150 years. His Festspiele is on a hill, protected from urban reality by rising lawns; private vehicles are prohibited. As the time for the first of the four operas approached, the ticket-holders with me among them walked up the slope in small groups. We wore our Sunday best, some flamboyantly so, others more modestly, the older assisted by the younger. There was not much talk: all eyes were on the Festspiele rising up ahead, and the looming 6pm start. This was like heading to mass in rural Ireland in the 1960s minus the cars and kids. Wagner is our faith and the Ring his great secular statement.

The idea stayed with me though the most remarkable musical experience of my life that was to follow over the next few days. The operas were presented in the original German with no surtitles; like the old Latin Mass you were expected to know what was going on (and everybody did). There is no air-conditioning and neither water nor snacks are permitted even in the foyer much less the theatre itself. (There are wonderful stalls and restaurants scattered around the hill.) Remarkably, Wagner designed his theatre with the orchestra tucked under the stage, invisible to the audience, like a priest with his back to the congregation. The operas are very long it is true, but then Mass used to be in the old days as well, and like many of Wagner’s characters preachers in the pulpit often engaged in lengthy homilies which (just as with Wagner) flirted with tedium. One difference with Mass lay in the audience engagement. In our religious world the congregation get to participate through the ritual of shared prayer. Not the Wagnerian faithful: the hours and hours of music must be heard in total silence, a mere cough treated like a blasphemous roar. This probably explains the extraordinary scenes that greet the end of each Act but especially when the whole thing is finally over. I had not been prepared for this: feet thumping wildly on Wagner’s old wooden floor, shouts and roars of appreciation, curtain call after curtain call – a chance finally to participate. And celebrate an unforgettable communal experience.

And what is this fabled Ring about, what story does it tell? The rise and fall of the Gods, a war between worlds for control of a devastating power, a ring shaped from the Rhine’s gold. But the Ring I saw had no ring, no Rhine, no gold, no nothing of any supernatural nature – not even (to my slight disappointment I admit) the dragon that Siegfried slays in the third opera. Like the bible, the Ring has depths that defy a single narrative. There was a long literal phase; for fifty years after the composer’s death his grieving widow refused to change a thing. But his son and grandsons eventually got hold of the place and reinterpretation flourished. It still does, under the control now of Wagner’s great Granddaughter Katharina Wagner. My Ring was about power, family and the need to destroy the old order in order to give future generations a chance – the ring was a little kidnapped boy. The crowd loved it perhaps for and at least in spite of this. The grandest of dressers the most formal of attendees, turned out to be the most raucously progressive.

What of the Nazis? Like the Church the Wagnerian story has its shame, the horrible collusion between members of the dynasty (especially Wagner’s daughter-in-law, the English born Winifred) and Hitler himself in the 1920s and 30s, a great fan of the composer for the celebration of German values that he saw in his work. (And no one who has ever seen the non Ring work Meistersingers can disagree.) The Festspiele has thrown up boards explaining in painfully stark terms not just about Winifred but how anti-Semitic Wagner and his wife Cosima were. The memory of great Jewish musicians denied opportunities on account of their faith are scattered around the gardens. This could be something for those who run our own Festspiele St Peter’s to think about, remembering their own historic ugliness.

Towering above the unsavoury past, transcending even the most mediocre of productions, there is the music. There is nothing like it, the grandest most beautiful sound that human kind has ever contrived to make. If the Ring is too much, try Wagner’s great religious last work Parsifal – the funeral of Pope Francis reminded me of some of its extraordinary scenes. Or the most tragic love story of them all, Tristan and Isolde. If you fancy Bayreuth, then next year’s new once-off production of the Ring is a confection of the productions of the last 150 years, in which AI will appear on stage as a ‘generative visual force’.

26 August 2025